
“Three hundred years of being an innkeeper. Who knew immortality would be this terribly boring? Maybe next time I’ll screw up the sacrifice just to see if ‘L’ has it in him, her, it, to try to take me on!”
The City of the Dead (aka Horror Hotel; 1960) is an uneven tale of witches and their general motivations, in which the survivors of the persecution of witches in Whitewood, MA, possibly on both sides, have survived from the 1690s to the 1950s. Fresh blood is needed, though, to propitiate Lucifer (not seen here) and maintain their immortality, so when student Nan Barlow comes a-calling to gather information for a paper on witches, she becomes a sacrifice. It’s a dangerous intellectual pursuit, apparently.
Romantic interest Bill Maitland discovers she was last seen in Whitewood, so after a barking session at her professor, played by Christopher Lee, he and a sidekick make the dangerous drive to Whitewood, stopping at the gas station for directions, just like everyone else, which must bore the gas station owner something fierce. Once there, they discover the antique dealer has left hurriedly, the inn keeper has barely heard of Nan, the inn’s housekeeper is upset, and the townspeople will barely speak with them. Maybe not even that.
Eventually they discover enough clues to find Nan’s body, along with the cute antique dealer who is about to be sacrifice number two, who they rescue. Lucifer becomes mad about the missing sacrifice, and a whole lot of dead people end up … deader? Add in the sidekick, dying heroically, and it’s a goodly number.
Yes, the plot is a bit silly, but as I’ve said before, the charm of earnest horror eludes me; corny horror, however, can amuse me. Still, this plot had some egregious holes in it, such as the point of the professor in this story.
And why seek immortality?
On the other hand, the cinematography is gorgeous; the fog is overblown; the cars ponderous; and Maitland’s lack of reaction to the sacrifice of his fiancé is a disturbing big bell that falls unexpectedly flat.
If you are a Lee completist then you have to see this, but otherwise it’s for horror aficionados only.





