All Your Money Bought Little More Than A Lollipop

I can dig out the sources for this post, or I can simply reference Professor Richardson’s post of a couple of days ago:

Michelle Goldberg of the New York Times noted today that the only person who took a bigger hit on Tuesday than Donald Trump was billionaire Elon Musk. Musk poured almost a half a billion dollars into the election in an attempt to preserve Republican control of the Senate and to guarantee that Texas stayed in the hands of Republicans.

Goldberg recalls that Musk almost single-handedly funded the campaign of Republican Senate candidate Ken Paxton, Texas’s current attorney general, whose opponent, Democrat James Talarico, won the election by 12 points. She also notes that it sometimes seemed that Talarico was running against Musk as much as he was against Paxton, at one point telling a rally: “Elon Musk wants our land. He wants our water. He wants our tax dollars. He wants his very own personal United States senator.” Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa also called attention to Musk’s power in the state through his relationship to Texas governor Greg Abbott.

Tremendous amounts of money poured into Texas, supporting both sides, for the various elections a week ago, and Democrats expressed misgivings about the potential Republican funding magnitude; they seemed to think votes were reaped by those spending the most money.

Throughout the campaign, polls consistently showed a very close race for Senate, mostly with James Talarico (D) leading the Senate race, although occasionally Republican nominee Ken Paxton would have a small lead; I didn’t pay much attention to the gubernatorial and other state-wide races, and certainly not to the House races, all of which I’ll not address further. How did the Senate race end?

Talarico defeats Paxton, 59% – 39%[1].

That’s a twenty point loss. Or, if you take Professor Richardson’s numbers, a twelve point loss. Either way, this race was supposed to be close, and it wasn’t.

The great avalanche of billionaire money, led by Elon Musk, not only failed, but appears to have backfired.

There are lessons to be learned by both sides, and I fear lesson-learning, anathema to the arrogant, won’t be occurring. But shall we try to draw those lessons from the chaos?

  1. Have a reasonable ideology. Is your ideology the result of purity tests and a race to the extremes? Is it the result of trying to be more arrogant than your competitors in your own Party? Then you can bet it’s not reasonable.
  2. Behave in an honorable manner. If your parents were to observe you during your time in office, or whichever political role you’re filling, even that of humble voter, would they be embarrassed and humiliated? Manufacturing and/or distributing lies, or consuming same uncritically, is not honorable, and you can’t twist them into honorable activities; whataboutism is simply evasion of responsibility. Voters have come to distrust the obviously dishonorable.
  3. Don’t assume you have to be the opposite of the other side. Good heavens, we’re all Americans here, and therefore we must agree on some things.
  4. Why were the Republicans wiped out? Why were only a few States Republican safe states? Why is Georgia blue? Why is Mississippi teetering, Florida and Nebraska on the edge, and Maine rapidly moving away from the Republicans? It wasn’t the tactics, it was the ideology. A pack of grifters terrified of defying a President in the grip of mental illness, be it pathological narcissism or simple dementia or even overseas blackmail, didn’t constitute a desirable product. The Mendacity Machine[2] wasn’t a desirable product. Blindly arrogant positions such as being anti-abortion, anti-tax, anti-vax, or anti-regulation were not acceptable products. All their effluvia of war and inflation should have told Republicans that they were unacceptable. The same basic idea applies to Democrats.
  5. Don’t assume a vote for you is a vote for all the positions presented.

I could go on, but I won’t. I’ll simply say this:

Money carries the message, but it doesn’t ensure its acceptance and collection of votes. The Republicans didn’t lose because of tactics or even people, but because of ideology and, in this case, being a bunch of stooges.


1 59% – 39% is the Ballotpedia numbers. The WaPo numbers are less impressive but more plausible at 55% – 43%, matching Professor Richardson’s quote, and still make the point.

2 The Mendacity Machine is President Donald J. Trump, notorious for his inability to tell the truth.

Bookmark the permalink.

About Hue White

Former BBS operator; software engineer; cat lackey.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *