It’ll Need The World’s Biggest Forklift

This is a fascinating example of crossover techniques in technology:

At over 600°C, a jet engine’s exhaust stands out like a beacon when seen in infrared, making it an obvious target for heat-seeking missiles – but a US Navy device might be able to thwart such missiles with ghost images projected in mid-air.

The traditional method of defence has been to eject hot flares to draw missiles away from the aircraft. This new approach would use lasers rather than pyrotechnics.

When focused to a point, a laser can produce a spot or filament of ionised gas in the air, known as a laser-induced plasma (LIP). The US military has long shown interest in LIP to create artificial lightning to defuse bombs or produce “non-lethal” effects.

Now, Alexandru Hening at the Naval Information Warfare Center Pacific in California is using lasers to create an array of plasma columns in the air. These are rastered like the beam in an old cathode-ray screen to create two or three-dimensional images in mid-air of ghost aircraft that can distract incoming missiles. [NewScientist]

It’s a fascinating idea for confusing thermal detectors, and transfers an old, obsolete technique for display technology using a phosphorescent material with … air. And, for those wondering about my forklift remark, the old cathode ray TVs seemed to get exponentially heavier as the screen size increased; the big ones, I should imagine, could require several husky men to deliver them to their customers.

How Much Influence Does This President Have?, Ctd

A reader catches me depending too much on the Axios summary concerning a CDC survey:

Um, it was 200 people who responded to the survey. Who knows how many people have actually done those stupid things. It could be 201 or it be 20,000+.

Oh, crap. Here’s the relevant section from the actual CDC report:

A recent report described a sharp increase in calls to poison centers related to exposures to cleaners and disinfectants since the onset of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic (1). However, data describing cleaning and disinfection practices within household settings in the United States are limited, particularly concerning those practices intended to prevent transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. To provide contextual and behavioral insight into the reported increase in poison center calls and to inform timely and relevant prevention strategies, an opt-in Internet panel survey of 502 U.S. adults was conducted in May 2020 to characterize knowledge and practices regarding household cleaning and disinfection during the COVID-19 pandemic. Knowledge gaps were identified in several areas, including safe preparation of cleaning and disinfectant solutions, use of recommended personal protective equipment when using cleaners and disinfectants, and safe storage of hand sanitizers, cleaners, and disinfectants. Thirty-nine percent of respondents reported engaging in nonrecommended high-risk practices with the intent of preventing SARS-CoV-2 transmission, such as washing food products with bleach, applying household cleaning or disinfectant products to bare skin, and intentionally inhaling or ingesting these products. Respondents who engaged in high-risk practices more frequently reported an adverse health effect that they believed was a result of using cleaners or disinfectants than did those who did not report engaging in these practices.

[Bold mine.] The Axios report was poorly written, and I didn’t double-check it. If I’d realized it was an opt-in Internet survey, I wouldn’t have paid any attention, because these depend too much on special interest from the survey taker. 39% sounds high because many of those who had not taken up a dangerous practice would also not have taken the survey, thus skewing the results.

My humble apologies.

How Much Influence Does This President Have?

From Axios:

The CDC released data on Friday from a survey commissioned to understand why more people have been calling poison control centers during the coronavirus pandemic.

What they found: Roughly 200 adults who responded to the survey in May said they intentionally inhaled disinfectants, washed food with bleach, or applied household cleaning products to bare skin to combat the virus — all of which are dangerous.

  • Fewer respondents reported drinking or gargling household cleaners and soapy water to fight COVID-19, or inhaling bleach and other cleaners.

No matter how you slice it, 200 is a very small number against the citizenry or the electorate sliced up by political leaning or not. While it’s certainly a tragedy that the President managed to influence anyone with his absurd and dangerous suggestion, statistically speaking, for a population of roughly 280 million adults, this is unsurprising only in that it wasn’t higher.

This speaks to the diminishing influence of this President. Even those who are still inclined to vote for him are applying critical analysis to what comes out of his mouth and not doing what he’s doing when it’s obvious. This is suggestive, but of course not dispositive, that the President will be less able to entice voters down his rabbit hole come November.

The 2020 Senate Campaign: Michigan

It appears Republican hopes in the Michigan Senate race are fading:

Biden, the presumed Democratic nominee, leads Republican Trump in Michigan 53-41, according to a poll conducted by EPIC-MRA of Lansing between May 30 and last Wednesday. …

U.S. Sen. Gary Peters, a Democrat from Bloomfield Township, leads Republican challenger John James of Farmington Hills, 51-36, with 13% undecided or refusing to say. [Detroit Free Press]

This is roughly twice the gap from the previous poll that had come to my attention with regards to Senator Peters (D-MI) reelection chances.

And, of course, Biden appears to enjoy a tremendous lead in Michigan. It’s still a long ways to November, and there are many possible potholes facing Biden, so he has to continue projecting bold leadership – from his basement – and concentrate on talking about the current incompetency in the White House, and detail how he’ll reintroduce competency and integrity to the White House. He almost must keep his constituencies confident that their concerns will be addressed, if he does win. Chief among these are the black community, who essentially forced the Democrats to choose him, and he must retain their confidence.

Keep an eye on the polls.

Belated Movie Reviews

They should have been on Survivor.

Lost In Space (1998) can never make it past its original pained premise. Earth is doomed to environmental disaster, but the Robinsons, with their trusty, if lascivious, pilot Major Don West, are blazing a path to the only other known livable planet in the Galaxy to, you know, maybe ruin it, too.

Yeah.

And two young Robinson kids will be occupying important posts. They happen to be prodigies with all the usual irritating stereotypical kid things.

Robot and Mr. Smith are there as well, and I will happily admit the robot is fairly cool.

It was sort of vaguely entertaining when I saw it in the theater back in ’98 – not to mention excellent CGI for the time. The action is non-stop, but then we get into time travel, with all of its conundrums. The audience applauded in ’98 at the end, but I did not when I saw it recently. The show is essentially themeless.

Not worth your time unless you’re a completist for any of the actors.

Don’t Mistake Data For Data

One of the problems of data analysis is being able to trust the results in the face of questionable data collection and coverage practices. For example, WaPo has a longish article on the problems of understanding the range and character of deaths of people by police force:

The Post started tracking fatal shootings by on-duty police officers after a Ferguson police officer killed Michael Brown, an unarmed black teenager, during an altercation after a convenience store reported a robbery in August 2014. That shooting set off demonstrations and sparked calls for reform.

Amid the turmoil, nobody could answer a simple question: How often do police shoot and kill someone? No one knew for sure, because no government agency kept a comprehensive count.

When The Post began tracking these shootings, it became clear that police were shooting and killing people about twice as often as numbers reported by the FBI, which collected voluntary reports from police departments. The Post’s database, which is regularly updated, relies on a collection of news media accounts, social media posts and police reports. …

The Post’s database relies significantly on reporting from local media outlets on shootings in their own communities. The amount of reporting done on individual shootings has declined, probably a victim of the continued cuts by local media outlets.

But fatal shootings by police have not slowed — even though the pandemic closed businesses, shuttered schools and effectively shut down much of American life for weeks on end. In May 2019, police shot and killed 74 people. In May of this year, police shot and killed 109 people.

WaPo maintains its own database because no one seems to have a reliable and official database available.

And:

Fatal shootings by police are a limited metric for answering larger questions about how police use their powers, experts said. Whether a shooting is fatal may depend entirely on a few centimeters in the trajectory of a bullet.

No nationwide data exists on how often police shoot and wound someone, or how often they fire and miss. And no comprehensive national data exists on how other kinds of force — such as chokeholds or the use of batons or stun guns — are used.

“The fatalities is a very good measure of some things, but doesn’t include the kinds of events and activities that we’re seeing all over the country that normally don’t lead to death,” said Alpert, the criminology professor. “Unless there’s an injury or unless there’s a complaint that gets traction, either we don’t know, or it doesn’t matter.”

So when we want to analyze the situation, it almost seems hopeless – the data is not trustable, not granular enough, and how do we measure the racism inherent in redlining and profiling and, say, the casual racism of this woman:

Many of the birds he spots stop by for the dense plants, so he approached the dog’s owner early on Monday with a request: Could she leash up the canine, as the park rules required?

Amy Cooper said she would be calling the police instead.

“I’m going to tell them there’s an African American man threatening my life,” the white woman told him, pulling out her cellphone and dialing 911.

Less than 24 hours later after a video of their exchange went online, she has lost her dog, her anonymity, and her job — the latest incident in a long, too-familiar pattern of white people calling the police on black people for any number of everyday activities: BarbecuingPlaying golfSwimming at a pool.

My point? Be careful when citing figures concerning police shootings – not only might they not be trustable, they’re probably not even applicable to the situation.

Please Be More Jaded

The staff at progressive web site The Daily Kos sees a Trump ad buy in Ohio, won by Trump in 2016 by 8 points, as a signal that Trump has already lost:

So they’re spending money to shore up Ohio, which is for presidential election purposes an irrelevant state! It’s as if Democrats spent money playing defense in Nevada, which Hillary Clinton won by 2.4% in 2016. Because if we lose Nevada (or Minnesota, another close 2016 state), we’ve already lost enough other states to call it a day.

Or to put it another way, Trump’s problem isn’t Ohio. His problem is that his national numbers have tanked, and because of that it’s potentially putting reach-states like Iowa, Ohio, and Texas in play. But Ohio isn’t going to cost him the election. It’ll be the seven battlegrounds that will fall to Biden long before—and by a bigger margin than—Ohio ever will.

So why spend money on such ads in Ohio?

So there are two options: The first is that Trump is dictating where money should be spent. It would be just like him to assume he knows more than the experts and usurp their judgment. It’s easy to imagine Trump seeing a poll showing him narrowly losing Ohio and panicking, then ordering his campaign to go on the air in a state that won’t be deciding who wins or loses.

That theory fits in with the kind of campaign Trump is running: one based on his own prejudices, score-settling, and whatever else his lizard brain demands. It’s the kind of campaign that thinks mocking Biden for wearing a mask is effective when 72% of Americans agree on the importance of wearing a mask. It’s a campaign build on getting cheers from the QAnon deplorables, not on winning the actual votes he needs to win an actual election.

The other option is that his campaign manager, Brad Parscale, is actually bad at his job. It’s not as if Trump has ever surrounded himself with the best and the brightest. So it’s not a stretch to think that Parscale is just another in a long list of failures inside Trump’s orbit.

Personally, I think they have to dig a little deeper in the swamp. The Trump Campaign has an amazing amount of money for a campaign that appears to be going down to defeat. By buying ads in Ohio, they’re transferring some of that money, sent by loyal donors, from their coffers to someone in Ohio. The Daily Kos staff might want to consider following the money.

Wouldn’t it be interesting if it turned out to involve firms under the influence of the Trump family?

Odder things have happened in politics. I’m not even sure it’d be illegal. But I’m guessing the fees would be steeper than usual.

When You’re Very, Very Wrong

In Texas, Reeves County GOP chairperson LaDonna Olivier manages to put her foot in her mouth and just about get it down to her gullet.

LaDonna Olivier, GOP chairperson from Reeves County, shared a post on Monday saying “people are trying to turn George [Floyd] into a saint” but he was a “brutal criminal.” [Texas Tribune]

How many ways can this be wrong?

  1. The police are the police. They are not judges, jury, or executioner.
  2. The police almost certain were not aware of George Floyd’s criminal record, if any. Suggesting that it was OK to commit homicide extra-judicially in this context is utter nonsense. Given their likely lack of knowledge, even this exceptionally weak justification breaks down.
  3. The entire weakness of Olivier’s argument suggests a bigoted position. This isn’t a thoughtful argument; instead, it uses some emotional trigger words, namely “saint” and “brutal criminal” in close juxtaposition. For those readers who don’t understand, or take seriously, such arguments, please purchase and read The Persuaders.
  4. And, finally, this isn’t a serious assessment of a situation in which protests are taking place in cities and towns large and small. In a WaPo article on the same subject, they quote her, although I don’t know the source of the interview:

    “I said he was no angel,” Olivier said in an interview. “My concern is all the rioting and people not knowing what’s going on, making something so huge out of it. There are more important issues of people dying or being killed. Nobody cries about the abortions. The police were wrong, but from what I’ve seen on his medical records he was high on drugs.”

    The reference to abortion is another use of an emotional keyword, a reminder that, Hey, the Democrats are evil baby-killers! if I may paraphrase the lost soul Erick Erickson. Olivier is speaking as GOP attack dog first, not as an American citizen faced with one of the most important and chronic issues which threaten the prosperity of the United States. Abortion is nothing more than a squirrel, an attempt to avoid having to address an issue at all. And, while there have indeed been reports of Floyd being high on something – fentanyl was one mentioned, although I’m a little surprised toxin screens came back so fast – all the videos I’ve seen of the arrest have shown a cooperative Floyd, not a combative man.

Only four. I’m a little disappointed in myself. Other thoughts?

The 2020 Senate Campaign: Arizona

It appears Arizona is sliding into an abyss that President Trump wouldn’t have believed existed. This is a Fox News poll (reformatted):

If the Arizona election for U.S. Senator were today, would you vote for (as of 30 May-2 Jun 20)
Democrat Mark Kelly: 50%
Republican Martha McSally: 37%
(Other) 3%
(Wouldn’t vote) 2%
(Don’t know) 8%

And, since we’re here, Trump trails Biden 42% to 46%.

The last poll I saw had Kelly with a 9 point lead; now it’s 13. As I always say, it’s a long ways to the actual election, but the poll trends have definitely been for Kelly and against McSally, who, from comments concerning the press, appears to be firmly esconced in the right win echo chamber. If this should continue, a 20 point loss would leave the Arizona GOP in ideological ruins.

But the loss of Arizona both in the Presidential and Senate columns would mark a definite rupture of the Republican firewall on which they’ve depended for their dominant position in the Senate, as well as holding the Presidency. Whether or not it’s loss would also mark the beginning of the dissolution of the Republican Party is a much murkier question to answer, though.

And Now They Need To Prove It, Ctd

In response to my piece on the NFL changing its position on taking a knee during the playing of the national anthem at football games over the last year, a reader writes:

He’d [Kaepernick] somehow have to become a very good quarterback for anyone to want to hire him. And not be a locker room cancer[.] Better players than him have been let go because they were an overall detriment to the team.

I’ve never paid attention to the NFL to the extent that I could comment on many players outside of the Minnesota Vikings, and I haven’t paid attention to the Vikes for a good decade, if not more. So my thoughts on the skills of Colin Kaepernick are confined to the observation that he was a starting Super Bowl quarterback, and, from what I read in a bit of research, a credible attack both on the ground and through the air.

But that was several years ago. If he’s lost a step or his arm is no longer good then he’s not as valuable. At age 32, he’s a trifle old compared to the average quarterback, but that’s apples and oranges – he’s had several years off from the grind and may be far healthier than that average quarterback.

But I suspect he’s not a danger of being a locker room cancer. I doubt there’s a significant number of black players that disagree with his stand on the issue of taking a knee, and probably most of the white players, if they didn’t before, will agree with him now. My sense is that the nation’s citizenry is rapidly learning how the black community has been oppressed over the entire lifetime of this country, and while some are resistant to learning – the police forces of certain cities seem to be enjoying dealing out brutality, for example – I am hoping most will figure it out. For those readers who may be feeling uncertain about the black community’s woes, WaPo published a fine piece on the matter. Recently, notorious right wing pundit Erick Erickson expressed doubt as to the reality expressed in the phrase ‘white privilege’, because he had worked his ass off to get to where he is today, wherever that might be. I would have to ask if he’s ever experienced anything like the descriptions in the WaPo article.

Endangering Human Health, Ctd

Some good news when it comes to Lyme Disease:

A new vaccine on the way should be effective against the six types of Borrelia that cause most Lyme disease in the US and Europe. “We are developing these vaccines for people living in the northern hemisphere on both sides of the Atlantic,” says Thomas Lingelbach, president of the French biotech company Valneva, which is running human trials of the vaccine. Depending on the type of bacteria, between 70 and 90 per cent of people in the trials develop antibodies, he says. The vaccine should be available in 2023. [NewScientist (6 June 2020)]

Given recent trends, this may be a very good thing:

Source: NewScientist

But I’m not sure of the relevance of this statement:

The trick won’t just be making sure that the vaccine works, though. It is also fighting anti-vaccine sentiment and building enough trust to get people to take it, says Lingelbach.

Lyme Disease is not transmitted directly human to human, but rather via the tick host. Unlike a vaccine for measles or the coronavirus, the menace of an unvaccinated human to human society is much lower; they are, in fact, mostly a menace to themselves. I’ve had the disease, and it’s not pleasant.

However, it’s not clear to me if my episode with the disease confers immunity, or if I’ll need a vaccination.

Word Of The Day

Zombie fires:

There is strong evidence that last summer’s unprecedented Arctic blazes appear to have smouldered through winter as “zombie fires” and reignited this month.

Intense blazes across the frozen north last year led to record carbon emissions that were on a par with those from Belgium, exacerbating the global warming that made the conditions for the fires possible in the first place.

Now as temperatures rise in the region and snow recedes, satellite analysis of last year’s burn sites and the fires erupting this month suggest many in Siberia may be zombie fires.

“We know they are real and quite rare. That’s why seeing so many potential spots in Siberia is interesting. The satellite images are astonishing, particularly the snowmelt immediately followed by the fires appearing,” says Thomas Smith at the London School of Economics. [“‘Zombie’ fires are burning the Arctic after smouldering under snow,” Adam Vaughan, NewScientist (23 May 2020, paywall)]

And Now They Need To Prove It

The NFL has seen the light finally? Is the unemployable former Super Bowl quarterback Colin Kaepernick finally  … employable?

This won’t make President Trump, Mr. Patriotism himself, all that happy, now will it? The NFL has just repudiated their implicit stand with Trump, and he’s not going to take it lying down. If he hasn’t spat some venom at them yet, he will soon enough.

It’s not been clear to me how the football fans have felt about the entire Kaepernick controversy. Was a majority just irritated super-patriots that’d rather not watch those who squatted when the anthem was sung? Could this cripple NFL finances as fans stay away?

But, on the other hand, many of the NFL’s star employees are black and in solidarity with the community that has been abused for so long. If they walked out, that would cause the NFL a lot of financial pain, once again. So there’s definitely a pincer movement; I’m hoping that it’s true, however, that this wasn’t a financial calculation by the people in charge of the NFL, but a moral decision forced by the clarity that the George Floyd murder and ensuing protests has brought about. They characterize it as a moral decision, but it’s a little hard to know for sure if you weren’t in the boardroom where this decision took place. I can only hope.

And then how does this affect the fans? This is a bit different, because I’m wondering if this will transform the attitudes of some fans. There will be the supporters of those who took a knee who will be pleased, of course, but what about those who were virulently against them? Will they ignore the situation? Call for a boycott?

Or maybe reconsider their position?

The NFL is one of the biggest sports machines in the United States and influences a lot of people a lot more than is probably really healthy. Managed properly, this announcement may be a big rock starting to roll downhill finally. It could even be a big, if subtle, piece of why President Trump doesn’t get reelected – or even resigns early.

But announcing the signing of Kaepernick will be necessary in order to confirm the NFL’s conversion to a morally defensible position.

The Nervous Nellie Doctor

This possible advance both amuses me and makes me wonder:

Generic fidget spinner.

A device inspired by fidget spinner toys can diagnose a urinary tract infection (UTI) in less than an hour, without the need for a laboratory or electricity.

The device takes advantage of the centrifugal force generated by spinning to push the urine sample through a membrane lining its interior. Any bacteria in the urine will be separated from the liquid and stick to the surface of the membrane. Adding a dye that stains bacterial cells orange will then reveal their presence within 45 minutes.

“It is easy to operate,” says Yoon-Kyoung Cho at the Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology in South Korea. One or two spins is usually enough to get a diagnosis, she says. [NewScientist]

Can this be generalized to handle other pathogens? Perhaps a dye specific to certain classes of pathogens? Distributed test processing, as I think of it, might take significant pressure of medical test processing. We already do this with glucose monitoring strips: a prick of the finger and the test gear, miniaturized in a little box, soon has your number for you.

On the other hand, I have to wonder if this would have a negative or positive effect on the environment relative to more traditional test processing methods.

Cracking The Whip On The President

Mayor Muriel E. Bowser (D) of Washington, D.C., has put President Trump in a bind:

D.C. Mayor Muriel E. Bowser renamed a street in front of the White House “Black Lives Matter Plaza” and had the slogan painted on the asphalt in massive yellow letters, a pointed salvo in her escalating dispute with President Trump over control of D.C. streets.

City officials said the actions Friday were meant to honor demonstrators who are urging changes in law enforcement practices after the killing of George Floyd, an unarmed black man, in the custody of Minneapolis police.

“There was a dispute this week about whose street it is, and Mayor Bowser wanted to make it abundantly clear whose street it is and honor the peaceful demonstrators who assembled Monday night,” said John Falcicchio, the mayor’s chief of staff. [WaPo]

President Trump is best served by ignoring this salvo, but generally he sees such actions as signaling weakness. I expect at some point we’ll see some sort of action. Certainly there will be some screaming and abuse on Twitter from the President. He’ll probably claim she had no legal right to do so.

And then the racists that rally behind the President will demand action as well. Perhaps they’ll resort to vandalism. Maybe they’ll get caught.

And the President will look weak again. After silence – and possibly better than – his best response would be to pull a Clinton and embrace the reality. But I doubt he’ll do that.

Word Of The Day

Interpled:

: to go to trial with each other in order to determine a right on which the action of a third party depends [Merriam-Webster]

Noted in “Why Is NSO Group Asserting Sovereign Immunity in WhatsApp Litigation?” Erik Manukyan, Lawfare:

As NSO Group notes in its reply brief, Republic of Philippines v. Pimentela case where the Republic of the Philippines was interpled in order to resolve its claim to disputed assets, lends some support to such an argument. Under Pimentel precedent, NSO Group correctly recognizes that “a case may not proceed when a required-entity sovereign is not amenable to suit.”

A Test For The Next President

The next President, whether it be Pence or Biden, will face a test involving symbolic elements of our Republic upon entering office. What is it? Here’s what’s gone wrong:

Alyssa Mastromonaco, a former top Obama White House aide who directed operations, decried what she called “an incredibly sad transformation” to the White House this past week.

“Laura Bush believed in opening the White House to the public,” Mastromonaco said. “Michelle Obama took that idea and expanded to the People’s House. She routinely would say, this was not ours; it belonged to the American people. And our job was to make sure there was not one child left in this country who didn’t believe they belonged there. Everyone is good enough to walk through those doors.” [WaPo]

If the defenses erected during the protests of the last ten days is not removed by the Trump Administration, it must be one of the earliest duties performed by the incoming President. Not only should the People’s House be available to the people, but it is good and right that there be a certain vulnerability.

People who live eternally in military gear do not make friends.

Narratives

Stories are, arguably, the most powerful medium for learning ever invented. Stories are constructed from narratives, which contain facts and causal relationships between the facts. The causal relationships are one of the key factors in judging a story – are they believable, to what state do they lead for each character, that is the meat of a story. That’s what makes the audience believe.

Today, on the national stage, we’re plagued with narratives.

FAR RIGHT WING

Senator Tom Cotton (R-AR):

But the rioting has nothing to do with George Floyd, whose bereaved relatives have condemned violence. On the contrary, nihilist criminals are simply out for loot and the thrill of destruction, with cadres of left-wing radicals like antifa infiltrating protest marches to exploit Floyd’s death for their own anarchic purposes.

These rioters, if not subdued, not only will destroy the livelihoods of law-abiding citizens but will also take more innocent lives. Many poor communities that still bear scars from past upheavals will be set back still further.

One thing above all else will restore order to our streets: an overwhelming show of force to disperse, detain and ultimately deter lawbreakers. But local law enforcement in some cities desperately needs backup, while delusional politicians in other cities refuse to do what’s necessary to uphold the rule of law. [The New York Times]

Cotton implicitly conflates the rioters with the protesters, two groups that are, by most reports, distinct and unrelated, as he calls for using overwhelming force to take away the rights of the protesters. He wants calm, peace, and people at work, regardless of their grievances, and he’s ready to use the US military to enforce his wishes against US citizens exercising their rights.

President Trump:

President Trump said Friday that the greatest thing that can happen for race relations in the United States is a strong economy, after he was pressed on whether he has a plan to end systemic racism in the country.

Trump’s comments came as he touted new unemployment numbers for May during remarks at the White House. He argued that the better-than-expected numbers are a good thing for minority communities at a time when the country has been roiled by protests in response to the death of a black man, George Floyd, killed last week in Minneapolis while in police custody.

“It’s the greatest thing that can happen for race relations, for the African American community, for the Asian American, for the Hispanic American community, for women, for everything,” Trump said. “Because our country is so strong. And that’s what my plan is. We’re going to have the strongest economy in the world. We almost are there now.” [WaPo]

As if the issue were the economy. He fails to connect the failure of American society to treat all minorities justly as a causative to their relative depressed economic standing. Have you heard the slogan With no justice there will be no peace? It’s also true that With no justice there will be no economic prosperity for the oppressed. Trump continues to demonstrate why isn’t qualified to be President.

AG William Barr regarding the clearing of peaceful protesters from Lafayette Square:

Barr claimed that protesters outside the White House on Monday were becoming violent, justifying his authorization for police to remove them.

“I saw the projectiles on Monday when I went to Lafayette Park to look at the situation,” said Barr, who was seen in the park before protesters were forced out. [NBC News]

It’s worth remembering Barr has been called on twice to resign by former DoJ employees over incidents in which he meddled in prosecutorial decisions, one in sentencing recommendations and one in the notorious Flynn prosecution in which he’s trying to kill the prosecution which he’s responsible for running against a man who has freely confessed, twice, to his guilt. Barr, I think, doesn’t like the narrative that Trump’s associates are often criminals, and tries to indulge in the fantasy that they aren’t by changing the story over which he believes he has some dominion.

Unsurprisingly, the far right fringe wants to return back to some rosie bit of history where they are permanently ascendant and, well, supply your own views of what they want. Their view of how society should run – orderly, good economy, everyone at work – doesn’t include the resentment that comes from the racism that accompanies such history. They’re trying to sell this narrative to the Trump base, the moderate Republicans, and the independents.

RIGHT-MODERATES

Former Secretary of Defense for Trump and retired General Mattis:

“I have watched this week’s unfolding events, angry and appalled,” Mattis writes. “The words ‘Equal Justice Under Law’ are carved in the pediment of the United States Supreme Court. This is precisely what protesters are rightly demanding. It is a wholesome and unifying demand—one that all of us should be able to get behind. We must not be distracted by a small number of lawbreakers. The protests are defined by tens of thousands of people of conscience who are insisting that we live up to our values—our values as people and our values as a nation.” He goes on, “We must reject and hold accountable those in office who would make a mockery of our Constitution.” [The Atlantic]

Former Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Mike Mullen:

It sickened me yesterday to see security personnel—including members of the National Guard—forcibly and violently clear a path through Lafayette Square to accommodate the president’s visit outside St. John’s Church. I have to date been reticent to speak out on issues surrounding President Trump’s leadership, but we are at an inflection point, and the events of the past few weeks have made it impossible to remain silent.

Whatever Trump’s goal in conducting his visit, he laid bare his disdain for the rights of peaceful protest in this country, gave succor to the leaders of other countries who take comfort in our domestic strife, and risked further politicizing the men and women of our armed forces.

There was little good in the stunt.

While no one should ever condone the violence, vandalism, and looting that has exploded across our city streets, neither should anyone lose sight of the larger and deeper concerns about institutional racism that have ignited this rage.

As a white man, I cannot claim perfect understanding of the fear and anger that African Americans feel today. But as someone who has been around for a while, I know enough—and I’ve seen enough—to understand that those feelings are real and that they are all too painfully founded.

We must, as citizens, address head-on the issue of police brutality and sustained injustices against the African American community. We must, as citizens, support and defend the right—indeed, the solemn obligation—to peacefully assemble and to be heard. These are not mutually exclusive pursuits. [The Atlantic]

Senator Murkowsi (R-AK):

Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska on Thursday praised former Defense Secretary James Mattis’ blistering critique of President Donald Trump as “true and honest and necessary and overdue.”

Murkowski said: “When I saw Gen. Mattis’ comments yesterday I felt like perhaps we are getting to a point where we can be more honest with the concerns that we might hold internally and have the courage of our own convictions to speak up. And so I’m working as one individual to form the right words, knowing that these words really matter so I appreciate General Mattis’ comments.” [NBC News]

The outrage felt and displayed by these conservatives – these true conservatives, to be precise – reflects and clarifies that principled conservatives, vs the current crop of extremists posing as conservatives, have, well, principles that they work off of. The second- and third- raters that make up the Republican Party don’t understand and thus react by lashing out, as we see above and in Trump’s reaction to Murkowski:

“Few people know where they’ll be in two years from now, but I do, in the Great State of Alaska (which I love) campaigning against Senator Lisa Murkowski,” he wrote in a pair of tweets. “Get any candidate ready, good or bad, I don’t care, I’m endorsing. If you have a pulse, I’m with you!”

And, of course, there is the super PAC formed by George W. Bush Administration officials I mentioned here.

But these folks are pushing the narrative that there are a set of conservative principles, enumerated or not, and Donald J. Trump does not act in accordance with them. These sorts of arguments should have a strong impact on those conservatives who look at Trump with some distaste, but still think the Democrats are worse. This is a signal to them that they need to reconsider their views as Donald J. Trump is revealed as one of the most damaging political figures to disgrace the national political stage.

CENTER AND LEFT

Perhaps the Portland Press-Herald of Maine says it best:

Our View: To President Trump: You should resign now

President Trump: We’re sorry that you decided to come to Maine, but since you are here, could you do us a favor? Resign.

You have never been a good president, but today your shortcomings are unleashing historic levels of suffering on the American people.

Your slow response to the coronavirus pandemic has spun a manageable crisis into the worst public health emergency since 1918.

We are also in the middle of the worst economic collapse since the Great Depression. There is no national strategy to recover from the shock that is disproportionately affecting people who were already struggling to make it.

Competency is their first concern.

And in the face of the worst civic unrest since 1968, with millions of Americans in the streets protesting systemic racism, you fan the flames.

In just the last week you gleefully tweeted about shooting fellow citizens; you goaded governors into escalating violent situations so they don’t “look like jerks;” and you authorized the use of rubber bullets and tear gas to clear peaceful protesters out of a public space so you could pose for a Bible-waving photo-op.

These are just a few examples of why you lack the character, maturity and judgment to lead our country in this perilous time. You should resign.

And just about everything else as well. Recognizing he’s a pig with lipstick, they may be the first major news outlet to call for his resignation.

But the problem isn’t just Trump. Here’s the Minneapolis City Council:

The Minneapolis city council passed a restraining order against the city’s police department at an afternoon meeting.

The restraining order is temporary and will still need a judge’s approval before being enacted.

The order bans the use of chokeholds by police and also requires police to report and intervene if the banned practice is used.

Additionally, the Minneapolis police chief must authorize the use of crowd control weapons, such as rubber bullets and tear gas, according to the order.

The order also requires timely discipline decisions and allows for civilian audits of bodycam footage.

“This is a moment in time where we can totally change the way our police department operates,” Mayor Jacob Frey said.

Frey said there were difficulties in the past to make change like this and “now we can finally get this right.”

In the order, which was obtained by CNN, the city council said it hopes to build “toward systematic change.”

Velma Korbel, director of civil rights for Minneapolis, said she hopes “state legislature will be compelled to act, to change the laws that impede the city for making the deep systemic change required, and the community has the demanding for decades.”

Many people, including friends of mine, have called for defunding the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD), and it may be necessary to defund, dissolve, and reform MPD from the ground up. This may be the start of that effort. I’ve often wondered if the misdeeds of police departments were systemic in origin, or the fault of deliberately introduced malcontent officers, whether by individuals or invidious organizations. It appears that the Council has decided it’s systemic and taking steps to deal with it.

SO there are competing story lines, and even as I type this Trump is insisting that he’s got another victory when it comes to the economy because the jobs report was better than expected. I will tiredly insist that celebrations are not in order for a month or more. He’s trying to build a story, in the face of a rhetorical hurricane, that somehow he’s a winner.

But even if the economy is in recovery mode, it doesn’t make him right for the job. The job now is to evaluate each story for its correspondence to reality, and kick out those who keep pushing stories that are destructive to the national health.

Word Of The Day

Iconoclastic:

If you describe someone or their words or ideas as iconoclastic, you mean that they contradict established beliefs. [Collins English Dictionary]

Noted in “Scientist behind Sweden’s covid-19 strategy suggests it allowed too many deaths,” Michael Birnbaum, WaPo:

A gruff, self-confident scientist with a mop of graying hair and an ever-present paper coffee cup in his hand, Tegnell has become an object of fascination both inside Sweden and abroad with his iconoclastic approach to the crisis. He shot down other countries’ attempts to close down their societies as a needless overreaction. He was so dismissive of Italy’s approach that he twice drew a reprimand from the Italian ambassador in Stockholm. He reported to police that he and his family have received death threats by phone, email and on social media.